fbpx

Which is the BEST Sleep Appliance? Mandibular Advancement Devices and Splints – PDP293

Panthera, ProSomnus, SomnoMed, TAP — is there actually a best sleep appliance, or just the best-marketed one?

Your patient has moderate sleep apnoea. Should CPAP always come first?

Can a patient wear a bruxism splint and CPAP at the same time — and what happens to the mask seal?

And the elephant in the room: can you prevent bite changes from a mandibular advancement device — or are morning aligners just making us feel better?

This episode is with Professor Fernanda Almeida, a full professor at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver whose research career has focused on sleep apnoea and oral appliance therapy. Jaz asks the questions the community keeps asking — and she doesn’t mince her words. Some of the answers make for uncomfortable listening, especially if you hand out morning repositioning appliances. It’s worth staying until the end.

Watch PDP293 on YouTube

Protrusive Dental Pearl: When a Patient Says “I’ll Think About It”

“I’ll think about it” is often a polite “no thanks” — and if the conversation ends there, you never find out why. Maybe they think the treatment will hurt, when you know it won’t. Two common mistakes: letting it go so you don’t seem salesy, and assuming it’s the cost (“we have payment plans available”), which puts words in the patient’s mouth.

Thinking is something we do in our minds, so ask: “What’s on your mind with that?” It lets the patient tell you the real reason — nerves, anxiety, or genuinely the fee — and then you can address that. Communication habits are hard to change, so rehearse it, practise it and reflect on it.

This Pearl comes from the Chairside Cookbook communication course by Dr Zak Kara. Protrusive hosts the course’s accountability group inside Protrusive Guidance and quality-assures its CE/CPD.

Join the Chairside Cookbook: protrusive.co.uk/conversations

What You’ll Take From This Episode

  • A decision filter for CPAP vs appliance — four questions that settle most cases before brand ever comes up.
  • Why the AHI is only the beginning — what else on the sleep study changes your recommendation.
  • Three appliance families — and the patient factors that point you towards one.
  • Splints, masks and CPAP together — how to avoid quietly sabotaging the machine.
  • The truth about bite changes — what happens in year one, year three and beyond, and what the newest data says about AM aligners.

Highlights of This Episode

00:00 TEASER
01:21 Which Oral Appliance Is Best for Sleep Apnoea?
03:07 How to Respond When a Patient Says “I’ll Think About It”
08:40 Is CPAP Always First Line for Sleep Apnoea?
11:25 Why Dentists Can Improve Sleep Apnoea Treatment Adherence
15:11 CPAP or Oral Appliance? A Patient-Centred Decision Filter
19:26 Can You Wear a Splint or Oral Appliance With CPAP?
23:55 Can You Trust the AHI on a CPAP Machine?
25:50 Nasal vs Full-Face CPAP Masks With an Oral Appliance
28:07 Types of Sleep Apnoea Appliance Compared
32:58 How to Choose a Mandibular Advancement Device
36:11 Why Thinner, Lower-Vertical Appliances Work Better
39:03 Do Morning Repositioning Appliances Prevent Bite Changes?
43:36 Bite Changes From Mandibular Advancement Devices: What to Expect
52:06 Can DISE Predict Oral Appliance Success?
55:51 Sleep Duration, Insomnia and Exercise: Beyond the Appliance
1:04:28 OUTRO

From the Guest

Professor Fernanda Almeida is a full professor at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver. Originally from Brazil, she completed a sleep-focused master’s before her PhD at UBC, and her research centres on sleep apnoea and oral appliance therapy. She teaches orthodontic residents and supervises master’s and PhD students, and speaks regularly at the American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine, European meetings, societies and online study clubs.

👉  Questions or speaking invitations: falmeida@dentistry.ubc.ca — she’s happy for you to follow up if she misses the first email.

References & Further Reading

Sources discussed in this episode:

  • Hamoda MM, Huynh N, Ayas NT, et al., Almeida FR. Continuous positive airway pressure and mandibular advancement splints: the CHOICE multicentre, open-label randomised clinical trial. European Respiratory Journal 2025;65(4). The combination/patient-choice paper discussed on tape.
  • Marklund M, Legrell PE. An orthodontic oral appliance: a randomized, controlled pilot study. Angle Orthodontist 2010;80(6):1116–1121.
  • Drug-induced sleep endoscopy (DISE) — research by Prof Olivier Vanderveken’s group (University of Antwerp) on DISE as a predictor of mandibular advancement outcome.
  • Lloyd-Jones DM, et al. Life’s Essential 8: Updating and Enhancing the American Heart Association’s Construct of Cardiovascular Health. Circulation, 2022. Adds sleep duration to the AHA’s cardiovascular health checklist.

Want more?

If you enjoyed this episode, check out: Implementing Sleep, Airway and Myo to Restorative Dentistry Part 1 – PDP262

Tags

#PDPMainEpisodes 

Listen, Subscribe, Earn CPD

Listen: Subscribe to the Protrusive Dental Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube.

This episode is eligible for 1 CE credit via the quiz on Protrusive Guidance.

This episode meets GDC Outcomes A and C.

AGD Subject Code: 710 Sleep Medicine

Aim & Learning Outcomes

Aim: To help dental practitioners make patient-centred decisions about oral appliance therapy for obstructive sleep apnoea — when to favour CPAP, how to select an appliance design for the individual, and how to manage and consent for dental side effects.

Learning Outcomes — by the end of this episode, dentists will be able to:

  1. Describe how medical history, sleep study findings beyond the AHI, symptoms and lifestyle inform a shared decision between CPAP, oral appliance and combination therapy.
  2. Differentiate the main categories of oral appliance and identify patient factors — dexterity, dentition, existing restorations, occlusion and vertical dimension — that guide appliance selection.
  3. Explain the nature and timeline of dental side effects of mandibular advancement therapy, the current evidence on morning repositioning appliances, and how to consent and monitor patients accordingly.
Hosted by
Jaz Gulati

More from this show

Episode 425